Fake NC Historical Markers

  • Thread starter Thread starter donbosco
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies: 7
  • Views: 211
  • Off-Topic 

donbosco

Iconic Member
Messages
1,505
Isaac Brooks was an early Chathamite and a prominent man involved in colonial and Independence Era politics and business. There are many stories about actions he may, or may not, have been involved in during those times.

In 1959 a petition was submitted to The NC Historical Marker Program for Brooks to be remembered with a marker. For some reason that petition was denied and no marker was erected.

In 1962 a marker was, nevertheless erected on “Ike Brooks Road” near #Bonlee and the banks of #TickCreek just off modern (New) Highway 421. The sign itself states, “Erected by The Brooks Association, ~ 1962.” I remember this sign in my earliest memories. It is located very near to my Deddy’s Homeplace near Sandy Branch.

In full, the marker reads: “Isaac Brooks (~1730-1825). One of Chatham County’s first two Representatives in the North Carolina Assembly, 1771-1773. He participated in the Regulator activities. Home stood 40 yds W. Family Cemetery 160 yds S.W. [Erected by The Brooks Association, ~ 1962].

No one can actually be sure how many unofficial markers dot the landscape of North Carolina and my guess is that most are paid virtually no mind. One key to legitimacy is that a marker must only be located on numbered state or federal highways, meaning restricted access routes, city streets, and SRs (State Roads) are not eligible for one. There are some other criteria that must be met. That something is not memorialized does not mean that it is not worthy of that recognition but rather that either it has not been submitted for consideration or that the application did not meet the requirements. See here for more on the specs: NC Highway Historical Marker Program | NC DNCR

Isaac Brooks IS commemorated in that area by a stretch of Highway 421 that bears his name running from the Chatham/Lee County Line to Troy Estate Road near the Chatham/Randolph border. That naming was done by The NC Department of Transportation in 1997 in recognition of the fact that in 1773 Brooks proposed that a road be built from Fayetteville (Then Campbelltown) through Chatham that takes a path very close to the modern highway.

In the photos is one of the Brooks marker and an actual NCDCR one (James Hunter, Regulator Leader) - look closely and you can see the difference. Most prominently the Brooks marker does not bear the official state seal but rather in the same spot a rendering of a tree, a millstone (?), and a running canine (a fox?).

Official markers also bear a Letter-Number Code. When the program began in 1935 the state was divided into districts (lettered) and within those areas the signs are numbered.

Now that you know this and what to look for, do you think that you might know of an unofficial marker somewhere?

IMG_6329.jpeg
 
I have no idea where any other unofficial markers are, but I'll certainly look when I'm near any markers to see if they're legit.
 
The North Carolina Department of Cultural Resources thanks you for your service!!!
 
I do kind of wonder how hard it is to get a historical marker. I'm sure there are plenty of families that would love to see some ancestor get a monument but it doesn't seem like they are everywhere.

At the same time, some of the ones you see are pretty obscure. I think there's one in downtown Raleigh about a guy that founded the North Carolina dental society. That does seem notable and he was the founder but not sure if that's historical marker worthy.
 
I do kind of wonder how hard it is to get a historical marker. I'm sure there are plenty of families that would love to see some ancestor get a monument but it doesn't seem like they are everywhere.

At the same time, some of the ones you see are pretty obscure. I think there's one in downtown Raleigh about a guy that founded the North Carolina dental society. That does seem notable and he was the founder but not sure if that's historical marker worthy.


Years ago getting a marker was clearly easier than it is today as the current committee hews pretty closely to the following set of criteria...

1.The significance of the subject must be statewide.
2.If a person, they have to have been deceased at least 25 years.
3.If a structure architectural uniqueness or value otherwise is not enough (That's for the National Register of Historic Places).
4.Applicants for historic markers must demonstrate these criteria are met by valid documentation (the committee decides this).

The Advisory Committee will often send an application back with suggestions for further documentation.
 
I've seen these non-State historical markers for a long time. I had just assumed that these were markers put up by locals because (a) the state was too slow, (b) the locals didn't want to jump through the state-mandated hoops, (c) most likely, they represented a parallel local initiative for historical entities/building/roads, that while important locally, just didn't have enough state-wide impact to warrant a state marker. Kind of a parallel to community colleges and the UNC system.
 
Back
Top