“…
On platforms like X, algorithms wove real stories alongside full-blown conspiracies.
On Sept. 29, an X user
suggested that the supposed presence of lithium provided a motive for someone to “modify” the storm, to steal access to the mineral. Prominent voices amplified the theory to millions of people.
Groups such as Veterans on Patrol soon picked it up. “Isn’t it ironic how much lithium is available in the areas targeted by Helene?” the group asked in a Sept. 30 Telegram post.
(
There is, in fact, a lithium mine in the North Carolina foothills about a 60-mile drive from Lake Lure. But that area wasn’t as affected, and the government cannot control a hurricane’s path. In an interview, Arthur said he did not want to talk about conspiracy theories, just his mission.)
The theory deepened. Chris Martenson, a right-leaning, conspiracy-minded author and influencer with more than 200,000 followers,
published on his verified X account that he had heard that residents in nearby Chimney Rock were told that their town “was being bulldozed, bodies and all and the land was being seized by the federal government,” possibly to mine lithium. (Martenson didn’t respond to requests seeking comment.)
…
In some hard-hit mountain communities of North Carolina, some people didn’t know what to believe. Residents here “don’t trust and have felt abandoned by the government,” said Chris Malcolm, a disaster response volunteer who also lives in Rutherford County.
In four local Facebook groups spanning three rural counties, as well in massive Helene-focused ones with 30,000 members, posts echoing misinformation became sandwiched between requests for helping stray dogs, finding generators for one needy family or another, and updates on power being restored.
… some people have told the agency, “we don’t want you here.” He can sympathize, since trusting them has been hard for him, too. “We don’t know if FEMA will help,” he said. “We are hopeful that they will.
[Vets on Patrol has been useful unloading supplies at the parking lot]
… Derrik Staley, a manager at the Ingles supermarket, said that he was happy to host Veterans on Patrol’s relief efforts, noting “how they’ve gotten bigger and bigger.”
“We appreciate them being here in peoples’ times of need,” he said.
Allen Hardin, a recently retired lieutenant with the Rutherford County Sheriff’s Office, sat in a patrol car. He said that since the threat against FEMA, the sheriff would probably keep an officer posted in the parking lot as long as the Veterans on Patrol operation remained. But there have been no issues for officers to get involved in.
“They’ll talk your head off,” Hardin noted of the group, “but that’s it.” …
… other volunteers also began to doubt Arthur’s glowing social media posts about his group’s assistance, which he used to call for more donations.
… Harris and Yoxall decided to confront Arthur directly. “We appreciate what you’re trying to do here, but you’re not part of this community, you can back off the supplies,” Yoxall said she told him.
And that’s when he snapped, they said.
“He was threatening me,” Harris said Saturday morning.
“Then it turned into people calling me last night, like, be careful. Be careful. Really, he’s talking a lot about you.”
After that, they decided to walk away.
On Monday morning, they went back, again telling Arthur to pack it up, showing the encounter on a video call with a reporter. The Ingles supermarket chain had also gotten involved, the women said. And the people who lent him the giant circus tent and massive trailers no longer wanted to be a part of this.
At one point, Arthur started running, blocking some people from picking up goods.
“Those are for the people,” Yoxall and Harris yelled. “Those are donations for people, for our community. Hey, that’s donations you cant touch that!”
“This is nuts,” Yoxall, stepping off to the side, exclaimed into her phone.
“You can call this the standoff in Lake Lure.”
Soon enough, Veterans on Patrol started packing up, and Arthur disappeared for most of the day.
Lake Lure police officers at the scene said that they were not filing charges and that the group was leaving on its own volition. …”