Israel Hamas War | Possible Ceasefire Deal between Israel & Hamas? / Ben Givr threatens to resign instead

  • Thread starter Thread starter nycfan
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies: 1K
  • Views: 17K
  • Politics 
Ramrouser said:
True, but that framework was going nowhere until Trump's "Hell to pay" threats to Hamas and his pressuring of Netanyahu to close the deal. Of course, we should also credit the IDF in knocking out Hezbollah/Iran to where they are unable to support the Hamas terrorists.
Click to expand...
The IDF gets most of the credit. They can now operate virtually anywhere east of Natanz.

www.businessinsider.com

Israel's Air Force blazes air superiority path to Iran's border

Israel's actions in the wake of Syria's collapse give it unprecedented power in the air — right up to Iran's border.
www.businessinsider.com www.businessinsider.com
 
farce© said:
Will Trump request the hostages be held until after he is officially inaugurated like Reagan did with the Iranian hostages?
Click to expand...
While that would be a trump like thing he would do, there is no need. Nobody is dumb enough to believe, not even Biden, that this isn’t happening because of his comments about releasing hostages before he took office. So trump gets the win, Biden gets a win, hamas gets to hang on to some hostages a little longer to further exploit their position, and Israel gets to hang on to the possibility that the war will start back up so they can chase futility of trying to kill all hamas fighters. TRUMP = WINNING.
 
lawtig02 said:
I can't wait for four years from now, when there won't be a single American willing to admit he voted for Trump.
Click to expand...
Didn't you say that "Donald Trump will never be POTUS again..?"

Sadly you are pulling against our country to succeed.

Regardless of who is in power why do you want him to fail? You are no better than the MAGA crowd.

You just view the policies from your perspective. Same as they do.

I've seen you do this for over 15 years. Why?

The world didn't end when GWB was POTUS. He fucked it up.. but it didn't end.

It wont now. And your hyperbole entertains you to a point you make posts like you do. Relax.

Find a hobby other than spending 16 hours a day on a message board.
 
HesNotHere97 said:
Didn't you say that "Donald Trump will never be POTUS again..?"

Sadly you are pulling against our country to succeed.

Regardless of who is in power why do you want him to fail? You are no better than the MAGA crowd.

You just view the policies from your perspective. Same as they do.

I've seen you do this for over 15 years. Why?

The world didn't end when GWB was POTUS. He fucked it up.. but it didn't end.

It wont now. And your hyperbole entertains you to a point you make posts like you do. Relax.

Find a hobby other than spending 16 hours a day on a message board.
Click to expand...
Oooh! Fun! Who are you? You won't be posting here four years from now when you've been humiliated by the guy you voted for, but enjoy while you have the chance!
 
HesNotHere97 said:
Sadly you are pulling against our country to succeed.

Regardless of who is in power why do you want him to fail? You are no better than the MAGA crowd.

You just view the policies from your perspective. Same as they do.

I've seen you do this for over 15 years. Why?

The world didn't end when GWB was POTUS. He fucked it up.. but it didn't end.
Click to expand...
1. The world came close to ending when GWB was POTUS. We needed a $750B bank bailout and the steady hand of Obama to pull out of that crisis. Imagine if Sarah Palin was president in January 2009. And Palin is a genius compared to Trump.

2. It's not so much wanting him to fail as just expecting it. What he keeps talking about doing will decimate the economy. Have you ever considered this? If Trump raises tariffs on everyone, everyone will raise tariffs on us. And not on them. So in every country, American companies will face a 10-20% price disadvantage. Thus will exporters get killed. Will industry come back to the U.S.? No, it will not, because industry can't just pack up and move on a dime. And nobody is going to invest on the basis of tariffs that are almost certainly going to go away.

3. What you call "success" and what I call success are not the same. Trump being in power has all sorts of effects that he considers features and I consider bugs. Discrimination against LGBTQ people -- which has been on the rise since MAGA and is rising even more now -- is a bad thing. You probably consider it good, but it's bad.

4. Climate change. Since Trump is hell-bent on rolling back all climate progress that we have made over the past 15 years (which isn't all that much), and cajoling the world to do so as well, MAGA poses a long-term existential threat to the habitability of Earth for humans. That's a big factor for me. Like, a couple of years of prosperity (if it does happen, which is doubtful) is not worth the long-term damage it will cause.

Hurricanes are more powerful and bring more rain than they did. We've seen what that can do. Wild fires are more common and more severe than they used to be. We've seen what that can do (and remember the Canadian wildfires that spread haze and air pollution all over the US for a couple of weeks last summer)?

We've making that trade for 30 years: short term prosperity at the cost of long-term sustainability. And the bill is coming due. Both California and Florida have massive insurance crises. It's unclear whether property in those states is even insurable. Meanwhile, FEMA now spends $50B a year or more in response to floods and fires. It's way, way, way up from the 1990s. That is well more than ALL of the "Waste" in government DOGE has identified combined.

5. MAGA has no answer to climate change, so they just ignore it and you will too.
 
Oh. Look. At. That.

Not only is Israel still bombing Gaza into dust heaps, but there's now a convenient "obstacle" to peace.
 

Netanyahu delays the ceasefire vote, as far-right cabinet members threaten to quit​


“Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said a cabinet meeting that was scheduled to vote Thursday on the peace deal between Israel and Hamas has been delayed, in a blow to hopes that a ceasefireafter 15 months of fighting would take effect Sunday.

Netanyahu said that the meeting will only happen once Hamas pulls back on demands for what he called "last minute concession," adding in a statement that "Hamas reneges on parts of the agreement reached with the mediators."

He said that until the mediators notify Israel that "all elements of the agreement" have been accepted, the cabinet meeting would not proceed. He did not specify what elements of the deal Hamas had reneged on.

But in an interview with Al-Araby TV, a senior Hamas official, Sami Abu Zuhri, said there was no basis to claims by Netanyahu that Hamas was retracting parts of the ceasefire agreement. …”

——

 
nycfan said:

Netanyahu delays the ceasefire vote, as far-right cabinet members threaten to quit​


“Israel's Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said a cabinet meeting that was scheduled to vote Thursday on the peace deal between Israel and Hamas has been delayed, in a blow to hopes that a ceasefireafter 15 months of fighting would take effect Sunday.

Netanyahu said that the meeting will only happen once Hamas pulls back on demands for what he called "last minute concession," adding in a statement that "Hamas reneges on parts of the agreement reached with the mediators."

He said that until the mediators notify Israel that "all elements of the agreement" have been accepted, the cabinet meeting would not proceed. He did not specify what elements of the deal Hamas had reneged on.

But in an interview with Al-Araby TV, a senior Hamas official, Sami Abu Zuhri, said there was no basis to claims by Netanyahu that Hamas was retracting parts of the ceasefire agreement. …”

——

Click to expand...
1737061566859.png
 
Smotrich and Ben Givr (and Bibi) have been blocking this deal since the Biden Administration proposed this same basic construct in the Spring. Ben Givr seems fine being the heavy in this round so Bibi could make a promise to the Trump team that he almost certainly knew would be kneecapped. And I'm sure Trump will take up Bibi's claims that Hamas is to blame (and Hamas IS to blame for having the hostages in the first place etc., not trying to sanewash Hamas).

IMG_4573.jpeg
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top