Movies Thread

  • Thread starter Thread starter Rock
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies: 350
  • Views: 6K
  • Off-Topic 
I still have a few to see, but here’s my top 10 so far. Including docs and international.

Sing Sing *85
Anora *84
A Real Pain *83
Nickel Boys *83
Problemista *82
Aggro Dr1ft *82
No Other Land *81
Brutalist *80
Conclave *80
Civil War *79
The Substance *79

(Tie for 10th place)
 
A film I liked but is far overrated, like an overhyped Shakespeare in Love type thing of 2024, is Anora. The whole first half of this film is just teenager and hooker stuff but erotic, then the second half retreads things we have seen so very many times before, and is the kind of short story 1/3rd of an episode of The Sopranos delivered, and with much better acting and better black comedic realism.
Putting the pablum that is Shakespeare in Love next to Anora is such limp and shameful critique.

Anora does start out just as you describe. And it does evolve into a Sopranos episode just as you describe. But it does it with so much more nuance and skill than you dismissively deride it. Damn is it skillful and when Mikey and Yura Borisov are colliding against one another in a scene, goddamn it’s as good as anything gets this year. Top shelf. Well deserved as a frontrunner.

It’s a RIDE, so well done. And it gets better and better, and resets your expectations along the way.
 
Last edited:
You don’t even mention Sing Sing. Whaaaaat.
There are several I have written down as needing to see, and hopefully that one this weekend. Also on that list, Sleep, A Different Man, I Saw the TV Glow, Do Not Expect the End of the World, and some others. Last year was really bad for getting behind, but I really like to keep up with the best films.
 
Putting the pablum that is Shakespeare in Love
I thought Shakespeare in Love was just fine. Of course, I was working 60 hour weeks plus 2 hr/day commute at the time, so maybe I was just too tired to be critical. Was it really that bad, though?
 
Putting the pablum that is Shakespeare in Love next to Anora is such limp and shameful critique.

Anora does start out just as you describe. And it does evolve into a Sopranos episode just as you describe. But it does it with so much more nuance and skill than you dismissively deride it. Damn is it skillful and when Mikey and Yura Borisov are colliding against one another in a scene, goddamn it’s as good as anything gets this year. Top shelf. Well deserved as a frontrunner.

It’s a RIDE, so well done. And it gets better and better, and resets your expectations along the way.
I respect your opinion, but my view is a lot of the film is that rather tired stuff extended (eg., rich spoiled boy, look at all his wealth on display, the best of the prostitutes wins out, midnight strikes, bosses can't deal with her fighting back, this part just goes on, then one of them comforts her as some sort of ending). We could have learned about one of Putin's Russian oligarchs in some ways, but no. That is all I found, and it's too long, could have been done in 20 minutes of a TV show and has. I will watch again later this year to see if you're right but you can write about what I am missing if you choose. I liked it, but on this level I like a lot of films that do not matter.
 
I thought Shakespeare in Love was just fine. Of course, I was working 60 hour weeks plus 2 hr/day commute at the time, so maybe I was just too tired to be critical. Was it really that bad, though?
A lot of the grief it gets is because it picked up Oscars over better things, like best picture over The Thin Red Line and Elizabeth, or even Saving Private Ryan. That wasn't close to as bad as Crash or Kramer vs Kramer winning best picture, at least.
 
Shakespeare in Love was fine for a rom-com. It had no business being nominated for best picture, especially in the days of only 5 nominees, and especially had no business winning against that competition. I’m biased because I’m as big a Malick/Thin Red Line guy as you’ll find. But even though I knew it was too divisive to ever win, it still felt like a slap in the face for Shakespeare in Love to win. At least it could’ve been Private Ryan.

Harvey Weinstein bought those awards, plain and simple. One of (if not THE) most glaring cases of a marketing blitz turning a pretty average movie into a Best Picture.
 
Last edited:
I respect your opinion, but my view is a lot of the film is that rather tired stuff extended (eg., rich spoiled boy, look at all his wealth on display, the best of the prostitutes wins out, midnight strikes, bosses can't deal with her fighting back, this part just goes on, then one of them comforts her as some sort of ending). We could have learned about one of Putin's Russian oligarchs in some ways, but no. That is all I found, and it's too long, could have been done in 20 minutes of a TV show and has. I will watch again later this year to see if you're right but you can write about what I am missing if you choose. I liked it, but on this level I like a lot of films that do not matter.
Besides the incredible acting jobs, what hooked me were the tonal shifts. Partway through the movie I was thinking “this is a pretty fun romp but how is this nominated for best picture…” And then seamlessly, it unfolded and shifted to reveal more and more. Part romp, part thriller, part very poignant drama. Try doing that in a 20 min TV show.

Sean Baker is really skilled at that type of genre-shifting and keeping an audience off balance, and I think this is his best work. A great ride.
 
Probably the best movie you've never heard of... Hotel Mumbai.

Based on a crazy true story.


 
“Flow”
Out of Latvia.
No dialogue so don’t worry about subtitles.
Incredible film. You should watch it.
Academy Award winner
Festival de Cannes winner
 
“Flow”
Out of Latvia.
No dialogue so don’t worry about subtitles.
Incredible film. You should watch it.
Academy Award winner
Festival de Cannes winner
I’m usually not much for animation but I’ve intended to get to this one eventually.
 
Back
Top