I appreciate your post. Your perspective on the Court(s) is helpful to a layman such as myself.1. Roberts worked really hard to build a legacy that he has now completely trashed. I didn't see that coming. I don't know why he would do that.
2. I wouldn't have said never. I would have said unlikely, and the comparison would have been as you say -- comparing with the most cynical view. I was under no illusions that they would be merely bad. They were going to be terrible and it was obvious all along. But there's still a gap between "as bad as I can imagine" and "worse than I can imagine."
3. In fairness to me, Roberts did put up some resistance to Trump during Trump's first term. He gave all the appearances of wanting to be the adult in the room. A right-wing activist adult, but adult nonetheless.
4. I am very far from the only person who says "I still can't believe they did that." I think pretty much everyone who's had professional contact with a federal court was shocked by that. It was so absolutely beyond the pale, so devoid of any reasonableness from start to finish -- again, what was the point of John Roberts' legal career if he's just going to wipe it away by letting the Republic fall?
“I think pretty much everyone who’s had professional contact with a federal court was shocked by that.”
I have no direct contact with a federal (or state) court. I have had direct contact with Jesse Helms and his Congressional Club and other right-wing political activists. John Roberts is a right-wing political activist who happens to be Chief Justice of SCOTUS.
Citizens United and Shelby happened long before Trump came down his gawdy escalator.
I wasn’t at all surprised or shocked by the right-wing activism of the Roberts’ Court. I expected it. I expect it to worsen.