Hegseth ordered hundreds of generals to meet on short notice in Virginia


Good for the generals. Don't get me wrong. I still hope they follow their oaths and carry out all legal orders. Military coups aren't great either. But it sounds like we still have quite a few officers that aren't lap dogs just to get another star.
 
You're okay with the president using the military to arrest duly elected politicians that disagree with their policies? Or are you saying it's only okay to arrest politicians during a civil war?

With Trump in office, that's a bold position.
I'm not sure I agree with arresting opposing politicians over policy disagreement would ever be appropriate. But on the larger point, the fact that a "Rebellion" justifies things that are otherwise unjustifiable is in the Constitution:

"The Privilege of the Writ of Habeas Corpus shall not be suspended, unless when in Cases of Rebellion or Invasion the public Safety may require it." (emphasis mine)

In other words, it has been explicitly recognized from our founding that there are circumstances that would justify the suspension of certain civil liberties. "Rebellion" (like the Civil War) is one that was specifically enumerated. So while we can surely debate what, exactly, a President should be able to do in a time of rebellion, I don't find the position that some civil liberties can justifiably be suspended during a rebellion, even if at any other time it would be unthinkable, to be an unreasonable one.
 
I candidly cannot see a reasonable argument that Trump being assassinated would be good for the country.

If he dies of natural causes, that's a different scenario.
To be clear, OG, you are not posting in support of political violence, right? Just observing what you are concerned could happen if a disturbed person reacts violently this speech?
 
I candidly cannot see a reasonable argument that Trump being assassinated would be good for the country.

If he dies of natural causes, that's a different scenario.
hitting rock bottom would benefit this country in the long run but people are too dumb and gutless to even imagine it
 
You're okay with the president using the military to arrest duly elected politicians that disagree with their policies? Or are you saying it's only okay to arrest politicians during a civil war?

With Trump in office, that's a bold position.
Ideally should never be done, but your comparison is silly. It CERTAINLY should never be done for something so trite as disagreeing with on policy matter which has virtually no bearing on the welfare of the country as a whole. A real civil war - 1861-65, not sporadic street protests - well, I'd say that is far more debateable, and certainly within reason depending on the circumstances.
 
Ideally should never be done, but your comparison is silly. It CERTAINLY should never be done for something so trite as disagreeing with on policy matter which has virtually no bearing on the welfare of the country as a whole. A real civil war - 1861-65, not sporadic street protests - well, I'd say that is far more debateable, and certainly within reason depending on the circumstances.
Silly is that poster's specialty.
 
hitting rock bottom would benefit this country in the long run but people are too dumb and gutless to even imagine it
We know what hitting "rock bottom" looks like in this country - it was a Civil War that claimed the lives of roughly 2.5% of the population. A modern analogue to that could mean something like 9 million dead. It is absurd to call people "dumb" or "gutless" because they want to avoid that scenario. You act like we have nothing to lose, but we in fact have a whole lot to lose, especially because there's no guarantee we would come out of the other side a unified and stronger nation.

The issue is not that anyone can't imagine that horror - the issue is that anyone who welcomes such horror is insane.
 
I candidly cannot see a reasonable argument that Trump being assassinated would be good for the country.

If he dies of natural causes, that's a different scenario.
I agree. Trump being assassinated while in office makes him a forever hero in the minds of the maga cult. Trump dying of natural causes simply makes him an old fart whose clock finally struck twelve.
 
Back
Top