Iran Catch-All | IRAN WAR

  • Thread starter Thread starter nycfan
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies: 4K
  • Views: 124K
  • Politics 
CFordUNC said:
I don’t know, he’s on the verge of permanently crippling our ability to project true strength and hegemony abroad. We are completely cooked in the Middle East for generations to come, and the Chinese are watching and studying our every flailing move intently.
Click to expand...
Vietnam and Cuba were bigger issues and more significantly impacted our ability to project American strength and hegemony across the globe. At least as of today.

Iran's leadership has been culled and the military is weakened. It is not going to come as revelation to China that Iran has the ability to land a few missiles and drones at short-range targets in the Middle East. That is like State making a few baskets against Duke. No one thought it was going to be a shutout.

Now, maybe the complete brain drain in the DoD and the complete ineptitude of the Trump administration will eventually cause Iran to become a shitshow. But as of today, Trump has a long way to go to get to Bay of Pigs or Khe Sahn stupidity.
 
Calheel said:
Vietnam and Cuba were bigger issues and more significantly impacted our ability to project American strength and hegemony across the globe. At least as of today.

Iran's leadership has been culled and the military is weakened. It is not going to come as revelation to China that Iran has the ability to land a few missiles and drones at short-range targets in the Middle East. That is like State making a few baskets against Duke. No one thought it was going to be a shutout.

Now, maybe the complete brain drain in the DoD and the complete ineptitude of the Trump administration will eventually cause Iran to become a shitshow. But as of today, Trump has a long way to go to get to Bay of Pigs or Khe Sahn stupidity.
Click to expand...
Didn’t we technically “win” at Khe Sahn, though, at least in the sense that we forced North Vietnamese withdrawal with enormous casualties just before the Tet Offensive?

otherwise all fair points, for sure. Still, though, I can’t help but feel that the negative ramifications of this particular conflict will reverberate much deeper and for much longer than the failed Bay of Pigs invasion. At the very least we almost certainly have made it a heck of a lot more likely than it was last week this time that future attempted 9/11’s could occur.
 
CFordUNC said:
Didn’t we technically “win” at Khe Sahn, though, at least in the sense that we forced North Vietnamese withdrawal with enormous casualties just before the Tet Offensive?

otherwise all fair points, for sure. Still, though, I can’t help but feel that the negative ramifications of this particular conflict will reverberate much deeper and for much longer than the failed Bay of Pigs invasion. At the very least we almost certainly have made it a heck of a lot more likely than it was last week this time that future attempted 9/11’s could occur.
Click to expand...
Khe Sahn cost lots of money, equipment and lives -- only to be abandoned by us after the "victory." Meanwhile, it took our eyes off the ball and let the Viet Cong coordinate the Tet Offensive with troop movements that would have been obvious if we weren't obsessed with winning a battle over a base that we didn't even care about.

That is why it was such a tactical disaster. And Bay of Pigs, Iran hostage rescue, Vietnam and Afghanistan withdrawal, etc., etc. were just disasters period. Don't think we are at that level yet with Iran.
 
Calheel said:
Khe Sahn cost lots of money, equipment and lives -- only to be abandoned by us after the "victory." Meanwhile, it took our eyes off the ball and let the Viet Cong coordinate the Tet Offensive with troop movements that would have been obvious if we weren't obsessed with winning a battle over a base that we didn't even care about.

That is why it was such a tactical disaster. And Bay of Pigs, Iran hostage rescue, Vietnam and Afghanistan withdrawal, etc., etc. were just disasters period. Don't think we are at that level yet with Iran.
Click to expand...
And it could be a lot worse. Attacking a country of 98M with capability to regenerate arms and already widened the scope of the war in the M.E. carries the risk of throwing a hand grenade into a munitions dump.

Westmoreland was never going to win 'Nam. DOD and the Feds constantly lied to the American people about status, casualties, rationale for entering the war, etc. JFK knew better than to be drawn into the quagmire. LBJ did not.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top