Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
The animals trapped in human bodies Therians are neurological outliersTrump, is that you?
No, there wasn't kitty litter in the women's bathroom at a school. No, they were not eating the pets....
Looks like somebody just discovered AI chatbots and decided to create a new username!Ah, "superrific," your indignation is palpable, though regrettably symptomatic of a certain intellectual provincialism endemic to contemporary political discourse. Permit me to elucidate why your fixation on symbolic identity affirmation, however well-intentioned, is both strategically obtuse and epistemically reductive.
Ontological Myopia and the Fetishization of Identity
Nancy Fraser’s Redistribution-Recognition Dilemma
- Your argument presupposes that identity categories are axiomatic sites of political mobilization. However, as Judith Butler's Performative Acts demonstrates, identity is neither static nor innately coherent. Treating it as such risks reifying precisely the social constructs one ostensibly seeks to deconstruct.
Empirical Fallacies in Electoral Strategy
- Fraser's seminal work delineates the inherent tension between claims for cultural recognition and demands for economic redistribution. By privileging the former, contemporary progressivism engenders a political schema devoid of material exigency, thus alienating those whose lived experiences are defined less by symbolic affronts and more by economic precarity.
The Psychosocial Dynamics of Tribalism
- Quantitative analyses (see Piketty et al., 2020) unequivocally demonstrate that economic populism garners broader electoral appeal than identity-centric appeals. Voters, regrettably indifferent to postmodernist jargon, tend to prioritize policies that impact their material conditions rather than symbolic gestures of validation.
Historical Antecedents of Class-Based Solidarity
- Excessive emphasis on identity politics exacerbates out-group antagonism, as delineated by Tajfel's Social Identity Theory. This cognitive entrenchment undermines coalition-building efforts essential for durable political change.
In summation, while your zealous defense of identity affirmation may earn plaudits in the echo chambers of niche academic circles, it is tactically myopic and politically self-defeating. One might suggest recalibrating your rhetorical arsenal to include a modicum of empirical humility and strategic foresight.
- The New Deal coalition, a paradigmatic case study, succeeded precisely because it subordinated identity divisions to class-based solidarity. Labor historians have long extolled its efficacy in engendering structural reforms that benefited marginalized communities without fetishizing their identities.
I await your response, though I suspect it will be a postmodernist pastiche wrapped in impenetrable verbiage.
I'm just saying that of this list of things...Some are fairly self explanatory, I think. The only phrase listed there that can’t be deduced by just knowing the individual meanings of the words is identity synthesis, which I explained earlier in the thread. But it goes to show my earlier point that the message board medium isn’t a great place to discuss complex topics like this one with any degree of understanding between parties.
So, have you decided which bathrooms they can use and proposed legislation to ban medical treatments and generally marginalize them?The animals trapped in human bodies Therians are neurological outliers
![]()
No, there was not kitty litter in a school bathroom.
Yes, there was a woman eating a cat. She was not an immigrant. She was born and went to high school in Springfield Ohio.
I get it. It’s totally fair to not have the time to delve deeply into theory or political science, and I don’t expect the average person to. Like I’ve said, probably not a conversation suited well for a message board. If we were talking about it in person, I’d be able to explain things as they arise.I'm just saying that of this list of things...
Socialist left
Identity synthesis
Liberal Democratic left
Conflation between
Materialist socialist left
Identity focused left
Wokeness is…….
Social Justice politics
Liberal identity focused segments…….
I have zero clue where myself or people like myself would be placed. I assume you'd place yourself in "socialist left" but that's only because you use the word socialist to describe yourself. I honestly don't know what that word means in today's nomenclature either.
All of those seem to me to be really beyond my grasp of understanding the people you're referring to.
I think it gets back to this idea that I don't want to be a political scientist to have a discussion about elections. I fully admit that makes me low information, but it is what it is in that regard. I don't have the time or inclination to delve that deep into the political theory.
Whats likley sad is that words like "sigma" or "ohio" or "skibidi rizz" have more of an actual impact on daily life for most Americans than the terminology in that list does.
Yascha Mounk is a strange pick for a self-avowed Marxist. He's a reactionary centrist!I get it. It’s totally fair to not have the time to delve deeply into theory or political science, and I don’t expect the average person to. Like I’ve said, probably not a conversation suited well for a message board. If we were talking about it in person, I’d be able to explain things as they arise.
I really do think you would get something out of the book I recommended though. The author explains things better than me and with simpler nomenclature. Not sure if you perused the interview I posted with him, but it’s a condensed version of his argument from the book.
![]()
Yascha Mounk on The Identity Trap
Coleman Hughes interviews Yascha Mounk about how to make the case against the new ideas on race, gender and sexual orientation that have become so influential over the past decade.www.persuasion.community
I don’t think it’s fair to call him reactionary, but he’s certainly a liberal centrist. These are strange times; I obviously don’t agree with Mounk on everything, probably not even a majority of things. But he is able to lay out the mistakes of the postmodernist left better than any other author I’ve read on the subject.Yascha Mounk is a strange pick for a self-avowed Marxist. He's a reactionary centrist!
Marty, you know what he got here? Motherfuckin Charlie Bronson.I await your response, though I suspect it will be a postmodernist pastiche wrapped in impenetrable verbiage.
I don’t think it’s fair to call him reactionary, but he’s certainly a liberal centrist. These are strange times; I obviously don’t agree with Mounk on everything, probably not even a majority of things. But he is able to lay out the mistakes of the postmodernist left better than any other author I’ve read on the subject.
I also enjoy his podcast for the same reasons I enjoy this forum. I get to hear from liberals about how they view the world and current events. Like Marx, I came to socialism through liberalism, and I think it holds a lot of fundamental values that leftists of all stripes should find important.
From the perspective of a socialist, Left is Not Woke by Susan Neiman is also excellent.
First, has anyone noted a suspicious bulge in his cheek that could be caused by a tongue?Wisconsin Democratic governor proposes replacing 'mother' with 'inseminated person' in state law
Wisconsin budget proposal recommends changing 'paternity' to 'parentage,' and 'father' to 'parent' in certain parts of state law
![]()
Wisconsin Democratic governor proposes replacing 'mother' with 'inseminated person' in state law
Wisconsin Gov. Tony Evers is taking heat for introducing a bill with several changes to gendered language, including using the term "inseminated person" instead of "mother."www.foxnews.com
I think this is a legitimate concern. When one is working to undermine American ideals, customs and laws and can easily flee to another country, it should raise eyebrows.'New low': Longtime House Dem ripped for 'disgusting' questioning of Musk's loyalty to US as an immigrant
Rep. Marcy Kaptur, D-Ohio, sparked a firestorm on social media over comments questioning DOGE chief Elon Musk’s allegiance to the U.S. given that he has been a citizen for "only" 22 years.
"Mr. Musk has just been here 22 years," Kaptur said outside the Capitol on Wednesday. "And he’s a citizen of three countries. I always ask myself the question, with the damage he’s doing here, when push comes to shove, which country is his loyalty to? South Africa? Canada? Or the United States? And he’s only been a citizen, I’ll say again, 22 years."
![]()
'New low': Longtime House Dem ripped for 'disgusting' questioning of Musk's loyalty to US as an immigrant
Rep. Marcy Kaptur, D-Ohio, is facing heat on social media over comments made regarding DOGE chief Elon Musk's allegiance to the U.S. based on his immigration status.www.foxnews.com
What a shocker. Dumb American voters think Democrats are only focused on the issues right wing media tells them Democrats are focused on.Gift link
![]()
Many Americans Say the Democratic Party Does Not Share Their Priorities
A poll from The New York Times and Ipsos found that Americans believe abortion, L.G.B.T.Q. issues and climate change concern Democrats more than the cost of living.www.nytimes.com
Many Americans say they do not believe the Democratic Party is focused on the economic issues that matter most to them and is instead placing too much emphasis on social issues that they consider less urgent.
Asked to identify the Democratic Party’s most important priorities, Americans most often listed abortion, L.G.B.T.Q. rights and climate change, according to a poll from The New York Times and Ipsos conducted from Jan. 2 to 10.
The issues that people cited as most important to them personally were the economy and inflation, health care and immigration, the poll found. The kinds of social causes that progressive activists have championed in recent years ranked much lower.
As Democrats gather in Washington this weekend to elect the next chairman of their party, and debate how to most effectively counter the Trump administration, the latest public opinion surveys contain worrisome signs for them.
The country remains deeply divided over Mr. Trump’s leadership, with roughly equal shares of people saying that his second term is cause for celebration or concern.
But the poll suggests that people do not view the Democratic Party as an appealing alternative.
In a broad sense, the poll, which surveyed a representative sample of 2,128 adults nationwide, found that Americans think the Republican Party is more in sync with the mood of the country. The issues that people said mattered most to Republicans were also, for the most part, the issues that mattered to them: immigration, the economy, inflation and taxes.
Please boside better, or stfu. Please and thank you.'New low': Longtime House Dem ripped for 'disgusting' questioning of Musk's loyalty to US as an immigrant
Rep. Marcy Kaptur, D-Ohio, sparked a firestorm on social media over comments questioning DOGE chief Elon Musk’s allegiance to the U.S. given that he has been a citizen for "only" 22 years.
"Mr. Musk has just been here 22 years," Kaptur said outside the Capitol on Wednesday. "And he’s a citizen of three countries. I always ask myself the question, with the damage he’s doing here, when push comes to shove, which country is his loyalty to? South Africa? Canada? Or the United States? And he’s only been a citizen, I’ll say again, 22 years."
![]()
'New low': Longtime House Dem ripped for 'disgusting' questioning of Musk's loyalty to US as an immigrant
Rep. Marcy Kaptur, D-Ohio, is facing heat on social media over comments made regarding DOGE chief Elon Musk's allegiance to the U.S. based on his immigration status.www.foxnews.com