I would offer a third option: A closeted, self- loathing gay man who was on the look-out for free sex. I did not know this factoid about Robinson before today. But this raises the possibility that he is a self-loathing, closeted gay man from the "I don't think so" level to the "99% certain" level. That he no longer seeks his thrills in video parlors strongly suggests he has found an alternative outlet for that part of him that he believes or believed is less risky. What ever that "less risky" alternative, I think it involves saying "how high" on the way up when who ever provided the alternative says, "Jump!"
Anyone want to bet that Josh Stein declines to press this issue out of a sense of simple common decency?