Mass Deportation and Immigration Catch-All | Trump “Gold Card” path to citizenship for $5 million

  • Thread starter Thread starter nycfan
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies: 1K
  • Views: 34K
  • Politics 
Badbehavior1015 said:
I dont know the cost. Is it any better to have homeless illegals in US as it is would to be homeless in their own country? Why are they happy here being homeless? Wouldn't they have a better chance of help if they were in the town they came from?
Click to expand...
Estimates of $300B to execute Trump's plan (that's taxpayer funded) which we know won't be well thought out (see border wall). Then compound the cost of deportation with the impact to our economy, which is estimated to be approx. $88B annually.

Then you include the impact to families.

See where this goes?
 
Badbehavior1015 said:
I dont know how many homeless illegals there are. We dont know the correct amount of illegals in the country much less how many are homeless. Do you have any insight as to how many there are?
Click to expand...
Now, why would anyone think you're a Trumper? Maybe because you decide that the top priority has to be homeless illegals and then three posts down you say you don't even know how many there even are.

A lot of migrants leave their towns because, you know, they are being persecuted or targeted by drug rings. If they return there, they face violent retribution.
 
Badbehavior1015 said:
I dont know how many homeless illegals there are. We dont know the correct amount of illegals in the country much less how many are homeless. Do you have any insight as to how many there are?
Click to expand...
Approximately 12M, with most contributing directly to our economy.
 
CallMeTyler said:
Then compound the cost of deportation with the impact to our economy, which is estimated to be approx. $88B annually.
Click to expand...
Do you have a link to that estimate? I think the impact will be considerably larger than $88B. It's possible that the $88B is the GDP produced by the deported people, which is way less than the true cost because it doesn't take account of disruptions.

If meat packing pants close or reduce output significantly, there will be a GDP hit to the entire community. And there will be a GDP hit to restaurants who can't serve food that they can't buy, to grocery stores who can't sell food that doesn't exist, and so on.
 
superrific said:
Do you have a link to that estimate? I think the impact will be considerably larger than $88B. It's possible that the $88B is the GDP produced by the deported people, which is way less than the true cost because it doesn't take account of disruptions.

If meat packing pants close or reduce output significantly, there will be a GDP hit to the entire community. And there will be a GDP hit to restaurants who can't serve food that they can't buy, to grocery stores who can't sell food that doesn't exist, and so on.
Click to expand...

Make sure you type correctly, especially after admonishing me for my mistake about Syria.
 
Enigma94 said:
If you voted for Trump that's not what you voted
Badbehavior1015 said:
I believe the deportation of illegals should start in the prisons. Deport them first, then go after homeless illegals. IMO, if an illegal can show they are working and are being productive, they should be given the opportunity to apply for citizenship at that time.
Click to expand...
Note remotely fair to those who are in line legally. Why would you reward people for cutting in line?
Click to expand...
 
CallMeTyler said:
Estimates of $300B to execute Trump's plan (that's taxpayer funded) which we know won't be well thought out (see border wall). Then compound the cost of deportation with the impact to our economy, which is estimated to be approx. $88B annually.

Then you include the impact to families.

See where this goes?
Click to expand...
Thanks Joe. Trump had it under control but you just couldn’t help yourself thinking about all those future dem voters moving into red states. Now we have to spend $300B to clean up his mess.
 
Taking the low end of their estimate that 20-25 million illegal immigrants are in the country, they’ll need to deport an average of more than 400,000 people per month during Trump’s 48 month term.
 
Callatoroy said:
Why do you think Biden ended “wait in Mexico”? It seemed to work.
Click to expand...
He didn't. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals did, and then the pandemic.

Why do you insist on spouting BS, when it has been explained to you so many times? You can't wish away the fact that Remain In Mexico was an unlawful policy. That's why the bipartisan legislation was necessary. All of Trump's bullshit was illegal and contrary to law.
 
1moretimeagain said:
Taking the low end of their estimate that 20-25 million illegal immigrants are in the country, they’ll need to deport an average of more than 400,000 people per month during Trump’s 48 month term.
Click to expand...
How many people did the Nazis shuttle to concentration and/or death camps over the four years after the Final Solution? The Khmer Rouge moved about a million people out of the cities in a matter of months.

The point is that deportation capacity depends in large measure on a) willingness to follow rules; and b) commitment of resources. If Trump tries hard enough, 400,000 deportations will be easy.
 
1moretimeagain said:
Taking the low end of their estimate that 20-25 million illegal immigrants are in the country, they’ll need to deport an average of more than 400,000 people per month during Trump’s 48 month term.
Click to expand...
And that assumes that they can stop all ingress.
 
superrific said:
How many people did the Nazis shuttle to concentration and/or death camps over the four years after the Final Solution? The Khmer Rouge moved about a million people out of the cities in a matter of months.

The point is that deportation capacity depends in large measure on a) willingness to follow rules; and b) commitment of resources. If Trump tries hard enough, 400,000 deportations will be easy.
Click to expand...

Do you really think Trumps going to kill illegals by shuttling them to concentration camps?
 
superrific said:
He didn't. The Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals did, and then the pandemic.

Why do you insist on spouting BS, when it has been explained to you so many times? You can't wish away the fact that Remain In Mexico was an unlawful policy. That's why the bipartisan legislation was necessary. All of Trump's bullshit was illegal and contrary to law.
Click to expand...
Trump wanted to run on the problem, rather than allow bipartisan progress while Biden was in office. He actively worked to block border security legislation.
He's gotten what he wanted. It's now his problem. I'm waiting breathlessly for his solution, because mass deportations will be an absolute sh!tstorm if that is all he's got.
 
Last edited:
Badbehavior1015 said:
Do you really think Trumps going to kill illegals by shuttling them to concentration camps?
Click to expand...
No, I do not. Do you see any words in my post that predict such a thing? The point is that huge numbers of people can be moved quickly if the will exists for it to happen.

Given what Stephen Miller and others have been expressly describing, I think it's fair to think that they have in mind something like concentration camps. Or maybe the Warsaw ghetto. Probably not death camps, one would hope.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top