Mass Deportation - Planning underway— Tom Homan to be “Border Czar”

  • Thread starter Thread starter nycfan
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies: 396
  • Views: 7K
  • Politics 
I understand that they are illegal. You don't understand my point about drive and ambition. And yes, they are doing jobs others won't. Don't tell that trash to someone in construction for 45 years. I worked around and with enough people of all types to have a damned good sense of who will do what. I also doubt any of the ones I worked around in the last 20 years were only making 50 dollars.
Again, they are doing jobs at a lot lesser pay across the board so dont tell me others wont do the job. They wont do it for that level of pay, correct. Just because you know a few who are paid fairly doesnt mean jack, jack. Reality is the majority are not paid fairly so people can make lots of money off of them. We do agree that the people hiring them illegally are to blame.
 
Again, they are doing jobs at a lot lesser pay across the board so dont tell me others wont do the job. They wont do it for that level of pay, correct. Just because you know a few who are paid fairly doesnt mean jack, jack. Reality is the majority are not paid fairly so people can make lots of money off of them. We do agree that the people hiring them illegally are to blame.
So your "experience" counts but not anybody else? Your eyes have to be brown.

What would paying those wages do to inflation? Why are you sure that would be enough? Can you grasp the concept that the irredeemably lazy that are native here are weeded out in large part by the very process of immigration?
 
Kristen Welker interviewed orangeturd He said deportations will begin with Murderers and rapists, Of course no one has any idea who these folks are-or they would have been arrested-yes even in "sanctuary cities'
So a bunch of ICE guys are going to be the brillant detectives that suddenly "find" all these murderers and rapists Because they can do a better job than NYC detectives .... you bet
 
Again, they are doing jobs at a lot lesser pay across the board so dont tell me others wont do the job. They wont do it for that level of pay, correct. Just because you know a few who are paid fairly doesnt mean jack, jack. Reality is the majority are not paid fairly so people can make lots of money off of them. We do agree that the people hiring them illegally are to blame.
I’ll ask again. How much more do the jobs need to pay before reliable American workers will do them? What does that add to the cost typical customers pay for the service you provide?
 
Im not trying to justify anything at all. I'm asking you the most surface level questions that will have to be answered of you remove millions of people (any people) from being workers in those industries.

What are your proposals to counter these easily foreseeable outcomes?

Oh, and the fact that these outcomes are so easily foreseeable is the reason nothing has been done by either party and the reason why it is laughable to think the Trump administration will follow through.

You want to turn the ENTIRE central part of the country blue in one election? Remove undocumented field workers. Pubs know this and thus will never tackle it.

Im not trying to justify anything at all. I'm asking you the most surface level questions that will have to be answered of you remove millions of people (any people) from being workers in those industries.

What are your proposals to counter these easily foreseeable outcomes?

Oh, and the fact that these outcomes are so easily foreseeable is the reason nothing has been done by either party and the reason why it is laughable to think the Trump administration will follow through.

You want to turn the ENTIRE central part of the country blue in one election? Remove undocumented field workers. Pubs know this and thus will never tackle it.
Everyone has a choice to hire illegals and you are 100% correct no party is going to do anything about it because its about nothing more than greed which both parties are controlled by. Illegals are no diff than guns and drugs...each are too engrained into our way of life. The people saying they are doing jobs legals wont do are fucking lying and are the very people hiring them illegally and profiting greatly from their misfortunes. Lets just be transparent about it and say the large majority are doing jobs at a shit wage so we can make more money. Kudos if you are hiring illegals and paying them a living wage, but you are still breaking a law, albeit a law not enforced. I have made a choice to hire vets who will do shit jobs at a very livable wage at my expense. Ive never had a problem finding workers.....never. i would have a huge problem finding vets who will do shit jobs at a wage illegals will do.
 
Kristen Welker interviewed orangeturd He said deportations will begin with Murderers and rapists, Of course no one has any idea who these folks are-or they would have been arrested-yes even in "sanctuary cities'
So a bunch of ICE guys are going to be the brillant detectives that suddenly "find" all these murderers and rapists Because they can do a better job than NYC detectives .... you bet
I'd argue that if they committed the murder/rape here that we should incarcerate them unless their host country agrees to jail them there..otherwise I'd worry that if we deport them they will be back in 3 months.
 
I'd argue that if they committed the murder/rape here that we should incarcerate them unless their host country agrees to jail them there..otherwise I'd worry that if we deport them they will be back in 3 months.
They think these there are a bunch of undocumented murderers and rapists who served their time and then were allowed back in the US population.

Just delusional thinking.
 
They think these there are a bunch of undocumented murderers and rapists who served their time and then were allowed back in the US population.

Just delusional thinking.
Conversely, we have sheriffs in large metros that are refusing to work with ICE when they have 'bad hombres' that are booked for offenses like DUI, assault, theft, or even driving around without insurance. That needs to change.
 
Again, they are doing jobs at a lot lesser pay across the board so dont tell me others wont do the job. They wont do it for that level of pay, correct. Just because you know a few who are paid fairly doesnt mean jack, jack. Reality is the majority are not paid fairly so people can make lots of money off of them. We do agree that the people hiring them illegally are to blame.
You are full of shit. My company has made repeated efforts to hire vets, ex-cons, basically anyone. It is a light commercial operation in a relatively large city and we struggle to find anyone to fill line positions - many at wages well above minimum with as much OT as you want and ample opportunity to move up with the least bit of initiative. Well, we have a decent percentage of Venezuelan asylum seekers (some Ukes and SE Asians) and they are BY FAR the best people we have. Only ones who consistently show up on time and work hard all shift. They pay taxes like anyone else and are massive contributors to the economy. We E-verify, so we wind up turning down dozens of folks showing up who want to earn $13-$16/hour with benefits. In a relatively poor part of town, but few American citizens seem interested.
 
You are full of shit. My company has made repeated efforts to hire vets, ex-cons, basically anyone. It is a light commercial operation in a relatively large city and we struggle to find anyone to fill line positions - many at wages well above minimum with as much OT as you want and ample opportunity to move up with the least bit of initiative. Well, we have a decent percentage of Venezuelan asylum seekers (some Ukes and SE Asians) and they are BY FAR the best people we have. Only ones who consistently show up on time and work hard all shift. They pay taxes like anyone else and are massive contributors to the economy. We E-verify, so we wind up turning down dozens of folks showing up who want to earn $13-$16/hour with benefits. In a relatively poor part of town, but few American citizens seem interested.
The following example has been posted repeatedly on here to illustrate what mass deportation and cracking down on illegal immigrants does to the economy, but Trumpers just keep conveniently ignoring it. In 2010 Alabama's GOP state government decided to do a major crackdown on illegal immigrants in the state. And it was a disaster. Within weeks farmers (many of them Republican) were complaining that their crops were rotting in the fields because they couldn't find people to pick them, and they started begging the state government to back off. I believe at one point the state was reduced to using convict labor to try and pick crops, but that was a failure too. Eventually the state government relented and backed off. The notion that businesses that rely on immigrant labor will be able to find nearly enough Americans to replace the lost labor is delusional, imo.
 
Illegals who commit crimes here are currently deported correct? I know that was happening under Obama, I assume it continued under Trump. I don’t know why they should have to go through court and prison here before being deported, assuming their illegal entry happened first.
 
Illegals who commit crimes here are currently deported correct? I know that was happening under Obama, I assume it continued under Trump. I don’t know why they should have to go through court and prison here before being deported, assuming their illegal entry happened first.
Depends on the severity. Most likely they would be imprisoned in far worse conditions in Latin America but I don’t think you could tell family of a convicted murder victim that the murderer’s fate is now at the whim of a foreign government.

That is especially true if it were a drug cartel issue where sending the person back might result in his release or escape.
 
Depends on the severity. Most likely they would be imprisoned in far worse conditions in Latin America but I don’t think you could tell family of a convicted murder victim that the murderer’s fate is now at the whim of a foreign government.

That is especially true if it were a drug cartel issue where sending the person back might result in his release or escape.
Hm, things to ponder. Thanks.
 
Among other issues, has anyone asked the Trump team yet:

1. How they plan to schedule and hold removal hearings for all these people, or if they don’t on what basis they plan to skip removal hearings (required as due process);

2. Where they plan to detain people pending removal hearings and/or deportation; and

3. Where they plan to find the manpower necessary to detain, hold, process, and manage the deportation of these people?
 
Among other issues, has anyone asked the Trump team yet:

1. How they plan to schedule and hold removal hearings for all these people, or if they don’t on what basis they plan to skip removal hearings (required as due process);

2. Where they plan to detain people pending removal hearings and/or deportation; and

3. Where they plan to find the manpower necessary to detain, hold, process, and manage the deportation of these people?
For the third point, I'm sure the GOP would have no trouble hiring plenty of prison guards/thugs to detain people from their base of embittered and resentful beta males who live online 24/7 and hate liberals because "career women" won't date them and they generally have better jobs. Being a prison or detention center guard would be a dream come true for many of these men. They could wear a uniform, carry a gun and nightstick or billy club, strut around and act tough and important, and rough up immigrants and anyone else that Trump 2.0 decides to incarcerate. And they could still spend most of their work time on social media posting selfies of how manly and macho they look now.
 
I'm very curious to see what happens on this issue. The way I see it there are three possible scenarios:

Scenario 1 Hard-Ass: Basically tries to deport everyone. To pay for it, they will slap a tax on remittances (which will in turn open up another revenue stream for the cartels...shipping money tax free). Local law enforcement in border stated is brought into the mix. Minimal due process. Maybe they carve out TPS recipients when they realize that Trump gave out some TPS exceptions. A mass deportation would have a significant impact on construction and agricultural sectors while exacerbating inflation.

Scenario 2 Build the Wall: Kind of like how they built a little bit of wall and pretended that they were close to building the whole thing. Once they see the cost of shipping out millions, they will decide on the dog and pony show. Say some 300k illegals are deported, but the Trump admin makes a big deal about those deportations (daily videos of flights leaving). Most will be illegals who have committed felonies.

Scenario 3 Invitation to leave: Come up with some major threat to induce illegals to self deport (a form of this has happened in the past). Strengthen e-certify to cover every US employer (no one ever talks about the US citizens hiring illegals). There will be some deportations mixed in as well.

All this fails to solve some structural problems with US immigration policy. The economy needs a healthy dose of unskilled labor that relies on migrant labor. It is basically impossible for an unskilled worker to navigate the process to migrate legally. Drastically reducing the number of illegals creates a labor shortage that needs to be resolved somehow (guest worker)...thing is I don't see the MAGAS ever being straight with their base.
 
Back
Top