an0maly
Distinguished Member
- Messages
- 287
This is 100 percent of what the director did not want to do. It raises questions of whether war journalism is any kind of cure for political tribalism, a mindset that war is the endpoint of, and how motivations of telling the truth can be lost to adrenaline thrills of being in the mix. Those states as allies reflect the utterly unpredictable chaos fascism taking hold might have, and how total power in the Oval Office might foster the strangest of all bedfellows, but to go into that is never any point the film is after. I thought it was one of the most unusual war films ever made, and one of the best of 2024. The ending of the film does not imply something good will follow--at all. All I felt at the end was the horror of human tribalism and its endpoints in the modern world.I didn’t really care for it. I liked the characters and personal storyline fine, but if a movie is called Civil War, I need to know why we’re fighting. How did Texas and California end up on the same side fighting against the US.
Currently, I think we could be heading for something like the film depicts, but it's just one of multiple bad scenarios.