- Messages
- 562
A New Deal With Moscow?
Trump’s bid for a pact with Putin recalls the efforts of FDR and other presidents.
GIFT LINK—> https://www.wsj.com/opinion/a-new-d...bb?st=2tNMwJ&reflink=mobilewebshare_permalink
“The true nature and the full price of President Trump’s Russia and Ukraine policies has become clear in recent days.
Mr. Trump believes that improved relations with Russia are necessary for the American revival he hopes to lead, and he is willing to pay a high, even stupefying, price in moral authority, alliance relations and Ukrainian territory to get his deal. Vladimir Putin understands this and will charge the U.S. accordingly.
… In offering Mr. Putin explicit recognition of a sphere of interest in portions of the former Soviet Union including Ukraine, Belarus, Georgia and Armenia, Mr. Trump is making larger and more consequential concessions than his 21st-century predecessors tried in their own failed attempts to reach an understanding with Mr. Putin.
And in offering to abandon American support for democracy promotion, Mr. Trump is returning to the studied silence on human rights that characterized Nixon-era détente.
… Given this history, the Kremlin will see any agreements with Mr. Trump as a temporary truce rather than a permanent peace. That limits the value of a deal. Moscow won’t accept permanent restraints on its behavior in exchange for temporary promises from Washington. …”
"[Trump's strategy] could pull Russia away from China ..."
Those are some Olympic-level mental gymnastics by Mr. Mead. He's apparently implying that Trump is some sort of 3D chess master in diplomacy. However, any sane person will recognize that Trump has no plan 'to pull Russian away from China' because he's merely a Putin fan boy.
"It is tempting but wrong to attack this strategy primarily on moral grounds."
Throwing Ukraine under the bus in some sort of bizarre attempt to lure Russia away from China is not only morally wrong, but strategically idiotic.
"Curbing Beijing’s rise without risking a war between the U.S. and China is both a great and a deeply moral goal."
This is true. But I think we can be certain it won't be accomplished using Trump's approach.
"If Trump policy were to end in a grand bargain with Russia that facilitated a long-term understanding with China, future historians might praise a strategy that contemporary observers largely condemn."
I have no idea what Mr. Mead is thinking will happen between Russia and China as a result of some sort of US rapprochement with Russia. I suspect Mr. Mead has no idea how this is going to happen either. I bet it sounded good when he wrote it though.
Last edited: