That opens them up to exploitation by employers who basically hold the sword of deportation over their heads. And it puts legal workers in competition with workers that can be treated like something on the bottom of your shoe. Of course that is basically happening today so maybe little change.
Yeah, but that was, like, a terrible deal. Because.
While we’re dreaming of impossible practicalities, I was thinking there can be some kind of amnesty if you at least can show a w2, or some other meaningful indicia of gainful employment.
The good news is the Democrats should have learned the lesson the hard way that working in good faith with Republicans is a losing proposition for them. The Dems gave away the whole damn farm and got nothing in return to get that bipartisan immigration bill- one that was the stuff of literal Republican wet dreams for three decades- ready to go to the floor for votes, and it *still* got tanked- despite being created by one of the most hard core Republican senators from one of the deepest reddest states- all because Trump didn’t want the bill passed in an election year.
$88 billion a year for the deportation costs would be a drop in the bucket compared to the GDP loss from mass deportations.Cont’d
“… As a first step, Trump’s advisers are discussing issuing a national emergency declaration at the border on his first day in office, which his team thinks would allow him to move money from the Pentagon to pay for wall construction and to assist with immigrant detention and deportation.
But the legality of such a move is unclear.
A national emergency, Trump’s advisers think, also would unlock the ability to use military bases for immigrant detention and military planes to help carry out deportations.
… A critical near-term priority is finding the money to pay for it. An estimate by the American Immigration Council, a liberal immigration group, estimated that an operation to deport the total number of people living in the U.S. illegally could cost $968 billion over more than a decade, or roughly $88 billion a year. …”
So, tariffs?
Democrats need to toughen up for sure when it comes to working with Republicans. I'm sick of Democrats trying to be "the adults in the room" and negotiate in good faith with Republicans and then just getting slapped in the face over and over again. Congressional Democrats, and the party leadership in general, badly needs to wake up, grow a spine, and just tell Republicans to go to hell when it comes to compromise bills. That's exactly how Republicans treat them, and they're not going to gain any votes by working with them. My fear is that Congressional Democrats are clueless and will continue to believe, against all evidence, that working with Republicans will somehow pay off down the road. They wanted complete control of the government, well, let them run things and solve them. Working with them hasn't gotten Democrats anywhere for at least the last 15 years.
You really are out of touch and are speaking like a true dummy…Its ton of White,Black.and Latina people that are legal that do these jobs…Man the left has no clue what is going on in this country with the real people…That’s the reason y’all lost this election…
Illegal immigrants make up 25% of the US construction workforce. Those are facts. Deportation of said workforce will send the housing market into a tailspin.
As someone posted recently, if you want to know how these mass deportations play out just look at what happened in Alabama in 2010. The Republican state government made an all-out crackdown on "illegals" and it was a disaster. Republican farmers were soon complaining that their crops were rotting in the fields because they couldn't get anyone to pick them, and shortly after that they were begging Alabama Republicans to back off, which they did.
China is already deep into the overturing in SA.
I’d love to empathize with folks who will struggle when the cost of goods increases but again, they asked for these policies.
And maybe you’re interested in educating yourself on this topic a bit more.
I don’t have to…I don’t go by news reports I work in the business…I know what is going on…And maybe you’re interested in educating yourself on this topic a bit more.
Definitely want to avoid those “dummy” labels.
A fifth of construction workers lack permanent legal status. Can the next president change that?
Illegal immigration has dominated the headlines during this election season, but building pros are calling for help to get skilled workers to jobsites.www.constructiondive.com
The problem comes when the educated elites have no humility or possess such arrogance that they try to tell you what is best for you rather than just educate or disseminate information.
Having some knowledge, either directly or tangentially, doesn’t grant you expertise. Choosing to ignore the research that examines the broader industry is exactly why we are here.
Not me. I’m gonna openly laugh at them. They will be quite literally getting what they want. Hell, in some respects, I’ll be pissed if he *doesn’t* follow through. Trump didn’t even try to hide that his policies would be devastating economically for the middle and working classes- he simply had Elon Musk start the narrative that a little economic pain is a good thing! Paying higher prices at the pump, at the supermarket checkout, etc. will be a minor annoyance/inconvenience for me, and certainly well worth the hard lesson in economics that many voters are about to learn.
You do realize this can be done without incurring labor shortages or creating inflation right?
cmsny.org
God beat him to it.Also, 45% of all agricultural workers are undocumented.
A Profile of Undocumented Agricultural Workers in the United States - The Center for Migration Studies of New York (CMS)
Agricultural workers in the United States not only support the US economy but are also responsible for keeping people across the country and the globe fed.
1978 had completely made an ass of himself here.