Eh, I think that is a lot more accurate of a description for how he left the second time. He left the cupboard absolutely loaded the first time when he went to Texas. The problem was the athletic director listening to the players and hiring the defensive coordinator Carl Torbush instead of actually conducting a national search for what, at the time, would’ve been one of the best college football jobs in the country. The reason the program collapsed after he left was because of back to back disastrous coaching hires completely crater the program. But the defensive players that Mack Brown left the first time were some of the best and toughest we’ve ever had, and went on to be some of the best pros we’ve ever had. He also left behind the consensus number one recruit in the entire country in quarterback Ronald Curry.
If UNC would have made a good hire in the immediate aftermath of Mack Brown departing for Texas in 1997, say a Butch Davis type or a Frank Beamer type or a Mark Richt, it would not have fallen off a cliff like it did. It may not have reached the lofty height of being ranked in the top three in the country like it was with Mack, but it would have continued to be the second best program in the ACC behind Florida State.
The reason that so many five star guys did not pan out under Mack Brown 2.0, in my opinion, is because the culture of the program in 2.0 was the complete antithesis of what it was in 1.0 – that is to say, it was a country club, warm and fuzzy, touchy-feely, feel good type program in 2.0. So much so, in fact, that many of Mack Brown’s former UNC players from 1.0 and I think some of his Texas players commented on how dramatically different he was in terms of coaching them hard the second go round.