i understand dean's position. ive met lots of people who say they are morally opposed to the death penalty in all situations. its easy to say. its another thing to have a commutation paper in front of you for a guy who shot up a church because he hates black people, or a synagogue because he hates jews -- and sign it.
i strongly believe that people like to think of themselves as braver than they are. if you haven't been tested, you don't know what you would do. I would think that, had I been at my lai, i would have tried to do something to stop it. but i dont know that. and while its possible that everyone there was a sadistic murderer, i think its more likely that some of the soldiers knew it was wrong but didn't have the guts to speak out. that sounds insulting, right? it just shows how much we live in our own armchair qb minds. it would have taken a lot of guts to try to stop my lai. are you sure you have that level of guts?
are you sure dean would have the guts to commute the sentence of a terrorist? are you sure he wouldn't sign 37 of the 40 and call it a good job?