superrific
Legend of ZZL
- Messages
- 8,991
I kept going. Fortunately, I didn't have to go far before running into this nonsense:
He would essentially agree with the conservative critique, but argue that this means you need a liberalism that is not just managerial but ambitious, Promethean, committed to self-creation and exploration. And that form of liberalism, in my view, is subject to strong and dangerous temptations. Sometimes they’re necessary temptations—a culture may need a little Prometheanism—but they can quickly lead it badly astray. The liberalism I described in Privilege tended towards a spiritually arid form of hyper-ambition; not Whitman and Emerson communing with the glories of creation, but: how do I get a job at McKinsey? Under conditions of prosperity, liberalism as a world-view had been transmuted into a purely instrumental, self-interested meritocracy.
Apparently the desire to work as a management consultant is a strong and dangerous temptation. Who knew? What the fuck is he ever talking about?
A culture may need a little Prometheanism? Does he know what that word means? I mean, it's not actually a word but I think he's trying to say that creativity is good. I'd agree. I'd say it in three words.
It's very weird to think of "liberalism as a world view" is about McKinsey. Pete Buttigieg did work there briefly, but then he left, right? I mean, if he's going to McKinsey hoping to find liberals, maybe someone gave him the wrong map. McK is, I think, in the world trade center these days. GroupM is there too, and it's full of creatives. Maybe Douthat should talk to some of them.
He would essentially agree with the conservative critique, but argue that this means you need a liberalism that is not just managerial but ambitious, Promethean, committed to self-creation and exploration. And that form of liberalism, in my view, is subject to strong and dangerous temptations. Sometimes they’re necessary temptations—a culture may need a little Prometheanism—but they can quickly lead it badly astray. The liberalism I described in Privilege tended towards a spiritually arid form of hyper-ambition; not Whitman and Emerson communing with the glories of creation, but: how do I get a job at McKinsey? Under conditions of prosperity, liberalism as a world-view had been transmuted into a purely instrumental, self-interested meritocracy.
Apparently the desire to work as a management consultant is a strong and dangerous temptation. Who knew? What the fuck is he ever talking about?
A culture may need a little Prometheanism? Does he know what that word means? I mean, it's not actually a word but I think he's trying to say that creativity is good. I'd agree. I'd say it in three words.
It's very weird to think of "liberalism as a world view" is about McKinsey. Pete Buttigieg did work there briefly, but then he left, right? I mean, if he's going to McKinsey hoping to find liberals, maybe someone gave him the wrong map. McK is, I think, in the world trade center these days. GroupM is there too, and it's full of creatives. Maybe Douthat should talk to some of them.