The thing I cling to is that every time there’s supposedly going to be a red wave, it’s the opposite. The polls are very discouraging.
I agree. Hoping the error this time is polls markedly overshooting their adjustments in an effort to capture Trump support.
What they got wrong in 2016 was just about everything; in 2020 the pollsters pretty well nailed Biden’s support but understated Trump support by overstating undecided and third party intentions. In 2022, they overstated generic GOP support and GOP votes in some Senate races.
Trump has not gotten over 47% support nationally in two prior elections, so I cling to that. Trump got 46.1% (to HRC’s 48%) nationally in 2016 and 46.8% (to Biden’s 51.3%) in 2020.
But in swing states this year in he got 48.1% in PA in 2016 and 48.8% in 2020; in MI, 47.5% in 2016 and 47.84% in 2020; in WI 47.22% in 2016 and 48.82% in 2020; AZ 48.08% in 2016 and 49.06% in 2020; NC 49.83% in 2016 and 49.93% in 2020; and GA 50.38% in 2016 and 49.24% in Georgia.
So Trump’s support actually grew slightly in all but one of those states from 2016 to 2020(!), with a significant 1.0 point downtick only in Georgia. And in those states he got at minimum 47.84% in those states in 2020, and nearly 50% in NC.
Best case scenario for Harris is polls have overcompensated for red votes and so are understating her support nationally and in swing states. But another more nuanced possibility is that the swing states are closer to the national mean b/c overwhelmingly Dem support has eroded in deep Blue states among working class voters - not nearly enough to put her candidacy at risk in those states but enough to eliminate the Clinton/Biden national total advantage. That would mean the national and swing state results should look about the same rather than Dems needing to be +3 nationally to win in swing states.
We won’t know until we know but since 2012, I’ve definitely thought that the side that is unskewing the polls is usually in trouble. This year, both sides have been unskewing at certain times but the late trends certainly seem to be favoring Trump and the GOP. To me, the real canaries in the coal mine have been the tightening of the Senate elections in Wisconsin and Pennsylvania. Anti-trans ads in both states seem to have been extremely successful.
Today, TBH, it feels like 2016 all over again (but with advance notice). The turnout doesn’t seem to be there like it was in 2020 but is surging more in rural areas (so far).
But Maybe GOP voters, authorized to use early in-person voting, are just surging in early voting and that is causing the eventual total GOP turnout to be overstated(??)