GOP & Policies toward/treatment of Transgender & other LGBTQ Americans

  • Thread starter Thread starter nycfan
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies: 1K
  • Views: 31K
  • Politics 
It is important to note that the “wait until they are adults for medical intervention” potion is basically every other country in the world. The US is currently outside the norm.
I remember that happening in 1789 also. That worked for a long time.

The body of a person doesn't belong to the state. There's not even a real case to be made any more that each individual represents valuable manpower. Automation and AI is exposing that fallacy. This one of many things that should be between patient, parents ,if they are minors and their doctors.
 
Last edited:
It is important to note that the “wait until they are adults for medical intervention” potion is basically every other country in the world. The US is currently outside the norm.
When did, what other countries do, become our standard?

I've heard that same argument in regard to GMO crops also, and it's equally as bad.

Some countries sentence people to death for gay sex, are those the ones we should follow?

Europe also approved thalidomide, it's probably good that the US FDA didn't approve for treating morning sickness as other countries did.
 
When did, what other countries do, become our standard?

I've heard that same argument in regard to GMO crops also, and it's equally as bad.

Some countries sentence people to death for gay sex, are those the ones we should follow?

Europe also approved thalidomide, it's probably good that the US FDA didn't approve for treating morning sickness as other countries did.
I think if you are a substantial outlier from other countries (both conservative and liberal countries), you have to look at your position and make sure you are extra comfortable with it because it would be one thing to be at opposite end with a third world country but all of Europe, Asia, etc is something else.
 
I think if you are a substantial outlier from other countries (both conservative and liberal countries), you have to look at your position and make sure you are extra comfortable with it because it would be one thing to be at opposite end with a third world country but all of Europe, Asia, etc is something else.
I can appreciate your opinion, but I believe there are more important variables in the decision making process than the positions of other countries. I would prefer those other variables be given greater consideration.
 
It is important to note that the “wait until they are adults for medical intervention” potion is basically every other country in the world. The US is currently outside the norm.
It is the opposite of the dominant position.


Virtually every European country allows trans blockers under 18, as do Chile, Australia, and Japan.

Wrong again. Over and over. And over. And over. Why can't you google before you type?
 
Damn.

"ASHEVILLE, N.C. (WLOS) — Transgender students say University of North Carolina Asheville's new housing policy requirements target trans students, UNCA says that’s false.

News 13 has confirmed an updated UNCA policy that dates back to 2013, that may force transgender students living in dorms to live with suitemates who’s sex they don’t identify with.

News 13 spoke with three students who received notice of an on-campus housing policy change. All report they are transgender. Each said UNCA is requiring documentation of their legal gender that may include their gender at birth.

The UNC Policy Manual on campus housing obtained by News 13 shows it was adopted by the UNC System on August 9, 2013.

The policy reads: “The constituent institutions shall not assign members of the opposite sex to any institutionally owned and operated dormitory room, dormitory suite, or campus apartment unless the students are siblings, parent and child, or they are legally married. This policy applies to housing assignments beginning with the fall 2013 semester.”

On June 11, UNCA’s Housing and Residential Life department sent a six-paragraph email to some students living in dorm rooms.

The email reads in part: “We are reaching out to you today with an update about Housing and Residence Life policy and procedures that will require a change in your housing assignment.” “Please schedule an appointment between June 11 and June 19 to speak with a staff member from Housing and Residence Life.”

“I’m in Aspen Hall on the first floor,” said Ryan Foster, a rising senior at UNCA who identifies as male. “The only separation that occurs is within the rooms themselves.”

Foster said the policy at UNCA says suitemates must be same sex, but dorms are co-ed on all floors. Foster is paying for year-round housing on campus.

Now Foster and other trans students said they’re worried and angered about new DEI policies and this housing change.

“I’ve been consistently identifying as male for longer than I’ve been a student here. The initial email they sent was extremely vague. It kind of sends a lot of people into kind of a panic," Foster said.

Foster said he called UNCA’s housing department and spoke with a staff member.


Foster is worried for other trans students on campus. He’s especially angry because UNCA for years has promoted itself as an inclusive liberal university, he said.

He finds the changing UNCA climate hypocritical and said policy changes have been extreme since the Trump administration took over.

“Right now, we’re just at a point where we’re trying to keep each other safe. All I want to do is exist. All anyone wants to do is exist," Foster said.

UNCA spokesman Brian Hart emailed a statement in response to allegations of the updated policy targeting trans students:



“I was drawn to this school because it had been advertised as very heavily left-leaning liberal arts school. Over at the library at the quad they used to have these giant banners, three banners. One of them was a pride flag, one was a land acknowledgement, and one I believe was a Black Lives Matter banner. All of those things are now gone.," Foster said. "They just cut a bunch of our liberal arts programs and they’re quickly turning UNCA into the opposite of what they’re still advertising themselves as. I’m concerned for my community here. I don’t know what’s going to happen.”



IMG_9525.jpeg

IMG_9526.jpeg
 
UNC-A, left wing leaning or not perhaps understands the difference in male and female. Absolutely absurd the idea that someone could send their daughter to college and she winds up forced to room with a male that thinks he is a female, or pretending to be a female, or whatever the case may be. Thing 20 years ago that were inconceivable and the plot of a silly south park episode are becoming reality.
 
UNC-A, left wing leaning or not perhaps understands the difference in male and female. Absolutely absurd the idea that someone could send their daughter to college and she winds up forced to room with a male that thinks he is a female, or pretending to be a female, or whatever the case may be. Thing 20 years ago that were inconceivable and the plot of a silly south park episode are becoming reality.
i'm sure you'd love for your daughter to be rooming with 20-year old versions of these people
bWzuXtZWwy28at4-8ms9BHM67wkny1kMaRBtuolOqbVfsgo24w.jpgAndrew_Joseph_White5188055.jpg
 
UNC-A, left wing leaning or not perhaps understands the difference in male and female. Absolutely absurd the idea that someone could send their daughter to college and she winds up forced to room with a male that thinks he is a female, or pretending to be a female, or whatever the case may be. Thing 20 years ago that were inconceivable and the plot of a silly south park episode are becoming reality.
what's the problem here? Explain like I'm 5
 
UNC-A, left wing leaning or not perhaps understands the difference in male and female. Absolutely absurd the idea that someone could send their daughter to college and she winds up forced to room with a male that thinks he is a female, or pretending to be a female, or whatever the case may be. Thing 20 years ago that were inconceivable and the plot of a silly south park episode are becoming reality.
You know, when the kids go off to school there is a good chance that they do lots of crazy things that you really don't want to know about. Unless you believe that a trans female roommate is going to be a physical threat to them, what is the concern? I recall seeing and learning a lot of things about life in college.
 
UNC-A, left wing leaning or not perhaps understands the difference in male and female. Absolutely absurd the idea that someone could send their daughter to college and she winds up forced to room with a male that thinks he is a female, or pretending to be a female, or whatever the case may be. Thing 20 years ago that were inconceivable and the plot of a silly south park episode are becoming reality.
What are you afraid of?
 
It is the opposite of the dominant position.


Virtually every European country allows trans blockers under 18, as do Chile, Australia, and Japan.

Wrong again. Over and over. And over. And over. Why can't you google before you type?
The trend is toward disallowing...

The UK is the latest country to ban puberty blockers for trans kids. Why is Europe restricting them?

.....
A handful of European countries – such as Sweden, Denmark, and France – have also moved to limit their use to research settings or in exceptional circumstances, amid intense medical debate over how to care for the growing number of children who identify with a gender other than their biological sex.

“We've shifted into a direction saying if we're going to stop normal puberty in certain young people, then we need to do it with our eyes open [and] collect the data very carefully,” Dr Ashley Grossman, emeritus professor of endocrinology at the University of Oxford, told Euronews Health.

 
Back
Top