Yeah, if you think John Edwards and Jimmy Carter are examples of left wing populists, I really don’t know what to say other than that’s an incredibly blinkered view of the range of political possibility.
Obama campaigned as a progressive populist in 2008 and was rewarded for it. He failed to deliver on change and governed from the center-right. Clinton is honestly the closest example we have to a left wing populist campaign in the style that I’m talking about.
His policies once in office were pretty bad from the perspective of a leftist, but he ran a populist campaign on economic issues.
I think that, and his aesthetic as a southern white guy, was much more responsible for his 1992 win than welfare reform or Sister Souljah.
I think you have a lot more faith in the modern Democratic Party’s ability to determine what wins elections and what doesn’t than I do. Not a great track record for them recently.