superrific
Master of the ZZLverse
- Messages
- 10,841
The idea that Trump wants to do this via executive order is sort of funny.
I am worried about him getting Republicans to change federal law to regulate the manner of elections to be no mail in votes (I don't recall right off hand the specific constitutional language). Suppose they were to do that late 2025 or early 2026. There's no way the Western states that rely primarily on mail-in voting could possibly be ready for that. So would the courts say, "ok feds yes you have the power to do this, but there has to be a lead time so that states can prepare themselves"? I know what Sotomayor would say. I know what Kav would say if Biden was pres. What would Kav say if Trump is pres? That's the question. The right answer, of course, is that the 10th amendment and federalism generally places some constraints on the ability for Congress to turn on a dime on complex endeavors. Would that be the SCOTUS answer? My gut says, no, they'd fucking let it happen. But there's a difference between allowing gerrymandering and greenlighting a rule that would essentially nullify the integrity of all the elections.
I am worried about him getting Republicans to change federal law to regulate the manner of elections to be no mail in votes (I don't recall right off hand the specific constitutional language). Suppose they were to do that late 2025 or early 2026. There's no way the Western states that rely primarily on mail-in voting could possibly be ready for that. So would the courts say, "ok feds yes you have the power to do this, but there has to be a lead time so that states can prepare themselves"? I know what Sotomayor would say. I know what Kav would say if Biden was pres. What would Kav say if Trump is pres? That's the question. The right answer, of course, is that the 10th amendment and federalism generally places some constraints on the ability for Congress to turn on a dime on complex endeavors. Would that be the SCOTUS answer? My gut says, no, they'd fucking let it happen. But there's a difference between allowing gerrymandering and greenlighting a rule that would essentially nullify the integrity of all the elections.



