Paine
Iconic Member
- Messages
- 1,001
If you think the boat-in-the-driveway MAGA head is remotely close to the kind of voter I’m talking about the party winning back then you’re on another planet, not me.Who is saying that?
I'm saying that people are not being honest -- either with themselves or with pollsters -- about what motivates them. Like, times are tough, but are they so tough that it's time to embrace fascism and concepts of plans and magic tariffs? Or are they predisposed to gravitate toward the extreme racism and xenophobia and will look for excuses to get there?
You're acting as if this is a new thing that has never happened before.
You are right to focus on the future, and I understand why the racism angle isn't appealing in that sense because it's really hard to change racial attitudes. But you keep talking about a political approach that has never worked in America and never will, in part because Americans don't actually prioritize economic needs over their religion or their social concerns. I don't care about your "material analysis." If you think "material analysis" is going to connect with people, it's like you're living on another planet.
The problem in a nutshell is that the GOP has the ultimate villain for all their narratives. "They." It's really hard to compete with they. They can do so many things. They are invisible. They hide in swamps or lurk in cities out of sight, but oh are they powerful. They pull the strings from wherever they are, and they are evil and godless and immoral. They can't be named, because they are too numerous; they can't be described, because they are too numerous and varied; and claims about them can't be evaluated rationally because nobody know exactly who they are or what they do.
It is really hard to compete with they. And hopefully, the GOP will fuck up enough that the voters will see how "they" duped them -- a very different they. But I fear the response will be tripling down on conspiracies.
We’re talking about a narrow band of voters that has voted for Democrats before but swung to Republicans in 2024.
Again, I really have run out of ways to explain this concept so either believe me or don’t. I’m focusing on going forward.