GOP & Policies toward/treatment of Transgender & other LGBTQ Americans

  • Thread starter Thread starter nycfan
  • Start date Start date
  • Replies: 1K
  • Views: 33K
  • Politics 
UNCatTech said:
You, again, are wrong. You keep using the assumption that the weakest male is far stronger and greater than the best female. That's the only way your premise works.

There are some women that could probably play men's sports on their level. There are many women that are far stronger and more athletic in general than their male counterparts.

The risk is no greater from a trans woman than from a bigger stronger cis girl. As an example, I'm sure that Serena Williams would mop the floor with you and 90% of male tennis players in the world. She could probably beat your ass too.

But you keep pretending that your lies are correct and that any male is stronger, more athletic, greater player, and a greater risk, it seems you make you happy to be consistently wrong and you are good at it.
Click to expand...
I brought this up to superrific, but he didn't respond.

Would you be okay with getting rid of Title IX, making all public school sports co-ed and having equal numbers of males and females on each team?
 
ZenMode said:
I brought this up to superrific, but he didn't respond.

Would you be okay with getting rid of Title IX, making all public school sports co-ed and having equal numbers of males and females on each team?
Click to expand...
I believe that is overly extreme for the very few trans female athletes.


So, would you admit that there is inherent risk in female sports even with just females playing? That there are different physical strength and athletic ability among girls? And, that it is not a given that a trans female will be the biggest and strongest on every team?

And an even better question, why do you keep fighting to take away an opportunity for a person who already has a very complicated life, to participate with the group that the person mentally identifies and is physically transitioning to be, knowing the importance of acceptance to everyone especially one that is in such a period of transition?
 
UNCatTech said:
I believe that is overly extreme for the very few trans female athletes.
Click to expand...
I'm not actually supporting that and I don't think most people would because it would be incredibly detrimental to female participation in sports.
UNCatTech said:
So, would you admit that there is inherent risk in female sports even with just females playing? That there are different physical strength and athletic ability among girls? And, that it is not a given that a trans female will be the biggest and strongest on every team?
Click to expand...
There is risk in female sports and significantly higher risk the more you add males into female sports.
UNCatTech said:
And an even better question, why do you keep fighting to take away an opportunity for a person who already has a very complicated life, to participate with the group that the person mentally identifies and is physically transitioning to be, knowing the importance of acceptance to everyone especially one that is in such a period of transition?
Click to expand...
I don't want to take opportunities away from anyone. I want males to play with other males because males have a significant advantage over females.

That's why a group of old guys can beat the women's national team in soccer....easily and the 1150th rank mail tennis player can beat the 57th ranked female tennis player.
 
Last edited:
ZenMode said:
I'm not actually supporting that and I don't think most people would because it would be incredibly detrimental to female participation in sports.

There is risk in female sports and significantly higher risk the more you add males into female sports.

I don't want to take opportunities away from anyone. I want males to play with other males because males have a significant advantage over females.

That's why a group of old guys can beat the women's national team in soccer....easily and the 1150th rank mail tennis player can beat the 57th ranked female tennis player.
Click to expand...
Zen’ you need go to youtube and watch “Battle of the Sexes, exhibition tennis match between Billie Jean King and Bobby Riggs that took place in 1973”. Billie Jean beat Bobby Riggs in straight sets, 6–4, 6–3, 6–3. Billie Jean could have given any male a good match. BTW… to my knowledge the USPS doesn’t have tennis team. ;-)
 
ZenMode said:
I'm not actually supporting that and I don't think most people would because it would be incredibly detrimental to female participation in sports.

There is risk in female sports and significantly higher risk the more you add males into female sports.

I don't want to take opportunities away from anyone. I want males to play with other males because males have a significant advantage over females.

That's why a group of old guys can beat the women's national team in soccer....easily and the 1150th rank mail tennis player can beat the 57th ranked female tennis player.
Click to expand...
You should follow around a group of female high-level high school and/or college athletes.

The good females play pick-up with males ALL THE TIME! Anson Dorrance encouraged his teams at UNC to play pick-up and competitive off-season leagues with men.

UNC Women’s Soccer, Hoops, Volleyball, Lacrosse, etc. play tough male/female pick-up games year round.

It’s like NYC hoops….the best players are always looking for good games.

The idea that high school and college age women can’t play safely with comparably aged males is ludicrous.

Why I’m posting on this thread and giving a transphobic/homophobic prick a woody, I don’t know.
 
Zoo_View said:
You should follow around a group of female high-level high school and/or college athletes.

The good females play pick-up with males ALL THE TIME! Anson Dorrance encouraged his teams at UNC to play pick-up and competitive off-season leagues with men.

UNC Women’s Soccer, Hoops, Volleyball, Lacrosse, etc. play tough male/female pick-up games year round.

It’s like NYC hoops….the best players are always looking for good games.

The idea that high school and college age women can’t play safely with comparably aged males is ludicrous.

Why I’m posting on this thread and giving a transphobic/homophobic prick a woody, I don’t know.
Click to expand...
Of course. It's great for the female teams to play the male teams in just-for-fun, exhibition or pickup games. Competing against superior competition is a good way to measure your ability and improve. Ask any pro team how important it is to have the best available bench players for the starters to practice against.

I'll be honest, the fact that there is so much pushback on what is a widely known, biological reality is just baffling at this point.

It's not a coincidence that
  • AB Hernandez finished in first or tied for first in every event she competed. It's not a coincidence that
  • The 1145th ranked male tennis player, as a last minute substitution, beat The 57th range female tennis player.
  • It's not a coincidence that an under 15 boys team beat the US women's team.
  • It's not a coincidence that Lia Thomas was irrelevant in men's swimming and started winning against women.
  • It's not a coincidence that Imane Khelif easily won the women's gold in boxing
And, it's not a coincidence that society is in nearly complete agreement that we NEED to have female sports (Title IX) and not co-ed as the best way to get females involved in sports.

Again, this isn't me pulling shit out of my ass. This is a known biological reality. Males have 40-60% more muscle mass and it gives them a clear advantage, which is why there isn't a single complaint or concern about trans MEN competing in male sports.

The only legit argument is "Well, there are so few trans women...who cares? You're making a big deal out of nothing!" My response is "It's nothing to you because you aren't the female losing your spot in the starting lineup. You aren't the female not making the team. You aren't the female missing out on the post season or coming in second when you should have won, or third when you would have come in 2nd. You aren't the female having your school records broken by a male."

Why are we prioritizing the feelings/experience of one over the feelings/experience of the many who are negatively impacted?
 
ZenMode said:
I'm not actually supporting that and I don't think most people would because it would be incredibly detrimental to female participation in sports.

There is risk in female sports and significantly higher risk the more you add males into female sports.

I don't want to take opportunities away from anyone. I want males to play with other males because males have a significant advantage over females.

That's why a group of old guys can beat the women's national team in soccer....easily and the 1150th rank mail tennis player can beat the 57th ranked female tennis player.
Click to expand...
You refuse to listen.

Your ASSUMPTION that ALL MALES have a SIGNIFICANT ADVANTAGE over ALL FEMALES, is INCORRECT. And it's the basis of your premise. It's the lie that the trumplican cult is selling and you have eagerly purchased.
 
tarheelbillie said:
Zen’ you need go to youtube and watch “Battle of the Sexes, exhibition tennis match between Billie Jean King and Bobby Riggs that took place in 1973”. Billie Jean beat Bobby Riggs in straight sets, 6–4, 6–3, 6–3. Billie Jean could have given any male a good match. BTW… to my knowledge the USPS doesn’t have tennis team. ;-)
Click to expand...
It's a waste of time, I've provided multiple examples to why his position is wrong.
 
ZenMode said:
Of course. It's great for the female teams to play the male teams in just-for-fun, exhibition or pickup games. Competing against superior competition is a good way to measure your ability and improve. Ask any pro team how important it is to have the best available bench players for the starters to practice against.

I'll be honest, the fact that there is so much pushback on what is a widely known, biological reality is just baffling at this point.

It's not a coincidence that
  • AB Hernandez finished in first or tied for first in every event she competed. It's not a coincidence that
  • The 1145th ranked male tennis player, as a last minute substitution, beat The 57th range female tennis player.
  • It's not a coincidence that an under 15 boys team beat the US women's team.
  • It's not a coincidence that Lia Thomas was irrelevant in men's swimming and started winning against women.
  • It's not a coincidence that Imane Khelif easily won the women's gold in boxing
And, it's not a coincidence that society is in nearly complete agreement that we NEED to have female sports (Title IX) and not co-ed as the best way to get females involved in sports.

Again, this isn't me pulling shit out of my ass. This is a known biological reality. Males have 40-60% more muscle mass and it gives them a clear advantage, which is why there isn't a single complaint or concern about trans MEN competing in male sports.

The only legit argument is "Well, there are so few trans women...who cares? You're making a big deal out of nothing!" My response is "It's nothing to you because you aren't the female losing your spot in the starting lineup. You aren't the female not making the team. You aren't the female missing out on the post season or coming in second when you should have won, or third when you would have come in 2nd. You aren't the female having your school records broken by a male."

Why are we prioritizing the feelings/experience of one over the feelings/experience of the many who are negatively impacted?
Click to expand...
We are not, you don't seem to understand that the many you are referring to are mostly maga cult members and not the athletes.

Go read about some of the sports teams that are openly embracing their trans teammates.

Then look at who's actually driving the complaints. It's the bigoted cult members.
 
UNCatTech said:
We are not, you don't seem to understand that the many you are referring to are mostly maga cult members and not the athletes.

Go read about some of the sports teams that are openly embracing their trans teammates.

Then look at who's actually driving the complaints. It's the bigoted cult members.
Click to expand...
In MAGA World only MAGAs count and have value. Those sports teams that are embracing their trans teammates have no value and are worthless in their eyes.
 
Mulberry Heel said:
In MAGA World only MAGAs count and have value. Those sports teams that are embracing their trans teammates have no value and are worthless in their eyes.
Click to expand...
They're being forced to do it by the liberal elite. They have the power to do anything.

Well, they somehow can't get enough people to vote for for them so they can win elections. Must be the same design flaw the super villain master of evil Biden zombie clone had that didn't quite pan out. Surely it's not mass MAGAt misconceptions.
 
Last edited:
IMG_7328.jpeg
Tony Winner Cole Escola. I think they look great but sort of wonder how they decided whether to be nominated as an actor or actress (there is not a separate LGBTQ+ category). In acting, do we really need gender-based competitions for awards?

I don’t actually care enough to have read up on the topic, just something that occurs from time to time when the awards shows get coverage. I tend to be interested tin the awards shows almost entirely from the (very shallow, I admit) fashion blog perspective.
 
MOUNTAINH33L said:
The only embarrassing thing I see is your homophobia and transphobia. Stay mad, you bigoted cunt.

Get Out Theatre GIF by Tony Awards
Click to expand...
I have absolutely no issue with homosexual or transsexuals. I have an issue with those who ignore science in favor of feelings and identity politics.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top